The Absolute Best (and Healthiest) Key Lime Pie

Ever since Pillsbury posted my Banana Cream Pie Bites to their Facebook page and one of their fans suggested a key lime pie version, I have been a woman on a mission: to make an even more perfect, low sugar, healthier version of this classic dessert recipe.  Perusing the internet only found me "healthy" versions that subbed in low-fat sweetened condensed milk instead of the full-fat version or used jello and cream cheese.   I knew I could do better. First of all...

I was shocked.

Have you looked at the back of a can of sweetened condensed milk lately? Oh.M.GEE.  22g of sugar, times TEN servings... for a grand total of 220g just added into the regular key lime pie filling.  And what about the "healthier" low-fat version? Even MORE sugar!!!

Introducing the Absolute Best Key Lime Pie:

That happens to have over 70% less sugar per serving than its sweetened condensed cousin.

The density and texture were superb. The sour of the key limes was perfectly balanced with the sweetness of the greek yogurt and banana/squash puree. No one will know this pie is healthier for them. I promise. 

Every forkful was heavenly.

Healthier Key Lime Pie


The Absolute Best (and Healthiest) Key Lime Pie // @noshandnourish


1⁄2 cup
Key Lime Juice (I used Nellie & Joe's Key West Lime Juice)
1⁄2 cup
yellow squash puree* (or use a Gerber Organics' bnana/squash pouch)
1⁄2 cup
Lemon Greek Yogurt
1⁄2 cup
Vanilla Almond Milk
2 tablespoons
Egg Yolks
Honey Graham Crackers (4 sheets, crushed - goes in the filling)
Graham Pie Crust
1 cup
Whipped Cream (for topping)


*I peeled the yellow squash first and then used the finest section of my cheese grater to get it as fine as possible. You could even puree the squash with the almondmilk using an immersion stick blender!


  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees. (I use convection)
  2. Combine all filling ingredients (everything except the crust and whipped cream) in a mixing bowl.
  3. Once thoroughly mixed, pour it into the graham pie crust.
  4. Bake for 40 - 45 minutes, or until all of the filling has "set" and is not liquid-y.
  5. Cool the pie for 15 minutes before putting in the fridge.
  6. Cool for a few hours before topping with the whipped cream.
  7. Savor each delicious bite!

Yields 8 Slices